Quebec Referendum #3: Beyond The Pedagogy Of Fear -Opportunity?

Posted on Tuesday, June 07 at 12:10 by PatriotPete
What Trudeau started by repatriating the constitution must be continued, not by the old boy's elitist club of premiers and the PM, but by the democratic actions of an informed citizenry, constituted within a constitutional constituent assembly whose members are not MPs with a vested interested in the old legal order, but members elected directly by the people of Canada. No doubt this view will not be popular, no doubt there are many who want to continue on with the prevailing legal/institutional relations--relations that give us this low-level democracy, captured as it is by capital, intent upon bowing to 'deep integration' and continentalist forces. We must not buy into the pedagogy of fearful propaganda that the mainstream political parties and the corporate press will be seeding within the consciousness of Canadians, a pedagogy that seeks to freeze us in historical time, that seeks to stifle the winds of change that are blowing over this nation. What is coming in Quebec may be an historical opportunity for all the people of Canada to become empowered and to modernize our constitutional legal relations. If Quebecers leave to form a sovereign nation, we sovereign peoples who remain outside of Quebec must not allow the prime minister and the premiers to decide our collective fate. Neither can we allow corporations, 'professional politicians,' the cadre of political parties, nor left or right wing 'think tanks' to complete or unduly influence that task. Rather it is our right, nay, our duty as citizens to reinvigorate this democracy and protect our sovereignty as a people constituted within a differently constituted independent state--a state that refuses the continentalist dream of one continent politically and economically united. The fact is that we as sovereign peoples on the northern half of this continent are day by day being 'sold out' to corporate America and its military-technological complex. The old order is failing all of us. Like Quebecers, we all deserve to establish new rules to govern ourselves. New rules to preserve our cultural, economic and social sovereignty. New rules to invigorate our democracy. If it takes the eventuality of another Quebec referendum to jolt us out of our collective slumber as we collectively slouch toward the nightmare of 'deeper integration'--this patriotic Canadian is all for it. [Proofreader's note: this article was edited for spelling and typos on June 7, 2005]

Contributed By



Article Rating

 (0 votes) 

Options




Comments

  1. by hoopoe
    Tue Jun 07, 2005 8:16 pm
    I seem to recall Rene Leveque signing the Constitution of Canada. As a matter of fact, he made a big stink about it after doing so, claiming he was stabbed in the back by the other premiers at the time. He even called it the night of the long knives.

    What Quebecers don't seem to understand is that if they want to be part of this country it has to be on equal footing with the rest of us; you don't get a united country by creating special laws for certain groups (as a point in fact look at all the special considerations Quebec already has and unity is far off). If they want to separate, let them vote for actual sovereignty and not some crap sovereignty association and let the question be crystal clear that this is what separation means (in other words, the teat will be withdrawn). Also, they should understand that a vote for separation doesn't mean a pretty little dividing line down their provincial border, as there are other details to be resolved, especially with regards to Natives in the North who indicated strongly the last time they have no interest in joining a sovereign Quebec. Also, there will have to be some form of repayment (we will take Montreal) for the net gains Quebec has made under equalization payments. After all, that money was not given to build a separate Quebec but to support a province as part of Canada.

  2. Tue Jun 07, 2005 11:09 pm
    If the first comment is any indication, I don' t believe Canadians are ready to acknowledge PatriotPete's idea. Again, Québec will be told it is Canada's way or no way. Most Canadians see nothing wrong with their current political system and this federated nation of ten unequal provinces. That makes them a long way off from being able to envision something new or better. <p>From what I can make of PatriotPete's suggestion, only a top to bottom shake up of how Canada works will save it from self destructing. This is so much more than just being about Québec. It is about first nations situation, it is about Western provinces wanting more say, it is about Ontario's ambivalence, about French communities survival etc... In this constant and rapidly changing world order, trusting in Canada's status quo is nothing but a death wish. So the idea for a new debate and a Canadian- wide political and democratic renewal is excellent and sorely needed but I don't think average Canadians are ready to revisit who and what they 'think' they are. I actually believe an independent Québec will have a better chance of adapting and that it will succeed in bettering their standing, more so than if it remains within a federalist system that has petrified and is not going anywhere.

  3. Tue Jun 07, 2005 11:11 pm
    Sorry, did it again. Above by michou

  4. Wed Jun 08, 2005 1:55 am
    ...hoopee...you're comments are completely wacky.
    Wake up and smell the rot, emanating from Ottawa,
    caused by a dysfunctional political system and quisling
    politicians ...that, per your many previous posts...is
    selling this nation & its people out to Corporate/Military
    America. Canada cannot survive as a nation the way
    things are, the old rules are failing us. This is not a
    time to wishfully hold onto old rules and power cliques
    which have failed us. Should the people of Quebec
    choose to seek sovereignty and a new begining for
    themselves, it is a large opportunity to
    re-write the rules of how the citizens in Quebec and the
    rest of Canada will govern themselves. It is very
    possible to reach a co-operative accord with Quebec
    that will benefit both the peoples of Quebec & that of
    Canada.
    You have seem to have bought the neo-liberal
    Capitalist State line 'hook, line and sinker.

  5. Wed Jun 08, 2005 12:45 pm
    I agree with the comments made above by michou.

    The only change I'd make is in revising 'top to bottom' to read 'bottom to top', as any change is unlikely to start from the top and work down and, at any rate, the changes required should start at the grassroots and work their way up.

    ---
    "When we are in the middle of the paradigm, it is hard to imagine any other paradigm" (Adam Smith).

  6. by michou
    Wed Jun 08, 2005 9:13 pm
    Thanks for picking up that 'top to bottom' wording Calumny. I had meant the opposite just as you explained it. My English translations do not always mirror my thoughts as well I as would like them to. I may be in need of a proof-reader in the next few months. Would you be interested ? ;)<p>---<br>« Il y a une belle, une terrible rationalité dans la décision d'être libre. » - Gérard Bergeron <br />



view comments in forum


You need to be a member and be logged into the site, to comment on stories.




Your Voice

To post to the site, just sign up for a free membership/user account and then hit submit. Posts in English or French are welcome. You can email any other suggestions or comments on site content to the site editor. (Please note that Vive le Canada does not necessarily endorse the opinions or comments posted on the site.)

canadian bloggers | canadian news