I quote: ‘EDMONTON (CP) - Health Minister Iris Evans says she wants Alberta to examine the possibility of having private insurance compete with the public health-care system.’ And then she goes on, ‘Evans says people are tired of waiting 18 months for hip surgery, so the Alberta government shouldn't be afraid to examine all options for private insurance.’
Indeed such obvious statements to address the brutal hatchet job you have done on our healthcare system is typical, yet so out of touch with the horrific, if not negligent behaviour of these administrations responsible. People are tired of waiting for surgery - of that I have no doubt. Those waits in part are because there are no beds, and there are no beds in part, because the Alberta government in all their wisdom and foresight for their third way, imploded a perfectly viable hospital, the Calgary General, and sold another perfectly viable facility, the Holy Cross. The Holy Cross is being used as a private facility now, so what could this government tell us that suggests it wasn’t viable as a non-profit public facility?
The federal government by withholding transfer payments for healthcare for years contributed to the decay of our system, and now the provincial governments are playing fast and loose to get their private system through the door. Certainly we can see who you are all serving and it is apparently not the population at large. To suggest that you care about the long waits is such an insult to the people of Canada. I believe that you have been listening to your own choir for so long that you cannot hear another voice in the room, and believe me that voice is getting louder!
You are clearly looking after the rich of this nation, opening wonderful doors and offering up beautiful healthcare treatment to ensure that these pampered beings do not have to suffer any more than is absolutely necessary. You are ensuring that your friends in the insurance industry, private hospitals and specialty care services have a free run in this country, and all the beautiful people will buy their $1,000.00 plate dinners and applaud your efforts.
Perhaps for a fleeting moment you might consider what each one of you and your respective governments were elected to do. You might look out on this vast domain called Canada, and consider that the population who you are expected to and paid to protect, govern and be responsible for and to, are getting poorer and sicker everyday!
I know the pharmaceuticals can provide you with plenty of sleep aids to help you sleep through the night, but how does it sit on your conscience, I ask you? How do you feel about further impoverishing the people of this great nation, how do you feel about succumbing to the pressure to please the corporation? How do you look yourself in the mirror and justify the horrors that others are living with in this country because of the decisions you have been making?
Take a look at the rising rates of Autism in this country, and the lack of research into the illness, the lack of responsibility for vaccine contamination with mercury and all the people living with those decisions? Take a glimpse at the seniors who can’t afford to eat properly because they are overburdened with health bills, have you observed the rise in food banks, or the juvenile diabetes, or the people living on the streets? Our healthcare system was put in place to ensure that Canadians would never have to suffer the horrors of loss of health and loss of services at the same time. Your mouths say you are protecting Healthcare but your actions say something entirely different. You really ought to take a look at what your policies are doing to this nation. To suggest that private insurance companies could assist in this matter, is to ignore the blatant evidence which says otherwise. Besides the fact that you have insulated yourselves from hearing the voice of the public, you have insulted the public intelligence by spinning this entire issue for the last 10 years.
Finally I cannot express in words my utter and complete joy in anticipating the next Federal election and there is a small consolation in knowing that Premier Klein is fighting for his throne against his own buddies. Canadians will be watching as you face the reality that Canadians are facing everyday, because of your decisions, its called struggling for survival. So out of touch with the people you have become that I wouldn’t be surprised to hear one of you exclaim, ‘Let them eat cake!’
I look forward to your response, although the form letters are getting a bit stale. Perhaps just acting on my suggestions and rectifying the situation would be more beneficial, cost efficient, productive and time-saving for us all.
Yours truly
Catherine Whelan Costen
Canadian Action Party Vice President and Candidate
Cc: Jack Layton, NDP
S.Harper CP
Gilles Duceppe, Bloc
Connie Fogal, CAP
Brian Mason, ND edmonton_highlands@assembly.ab.ca
Kevin Taft, Lib ktaft@albertaliberal.com
Federal MP’s
Media
[Proofreader's note: this article was edited for spelling and typos on September 14, 2005]
Note: http://www.mytelus.com/...

Kill the sacred cow and let's join the rest of the developed world.
---
If I stand for my country today...will my country be here to stand for me tomorrow?
Or maybe public expression is making its way home?<br />
Here is the story:<br />
<br />
news home<br />
Wednesday, Sep 14, 2005 <br />
<br />
Klein rejects private insurance for all medical treatments<br />
<br />
EDMONTON (CP) - Premier Ralph Klein has sharply rebuked his health minister for saying she would like a review into how private insurance might compete with all publicly funded health-care services.<br />
<br />
Klein says Alberta would never consider such a move despite what Health Minister Iris Evans said Tuesday.<br />
<br />
and it ends with 'But Klein says his government has no plans to go beyond allowing private insurance for hip replacements and other non-emergency procedures.<br />
<br />
Evans could not be reached for comment.'<br />
<a href="http://www.mytelus.com/news/article.do?pageID=news_home&articleID=2029744">http://www.mytelus.com/news/article.do?pageID=news_home&articleID=2029744</a><br />
<p>---<br>If I stand for my country today...will my country be here to stand for me tomorrow?
---
If I stand for my country today...will my country be here to stand for me tomorrow?
Make no mistake. I'm certain this WAS planned. I believe it started with an agreement between the Mulrooney government and the Reagan administration, to "harmonize" health care (read as privatize the Canadian system). This would have been in keeping with "the spirit" of our "Free trade" agreements with the US. Privatization of our health care system appears to have been on the agenda of our Corporate servants (better known as our government) on a continuous basis ever since.
Since our health care system was at that time excellent; it could only be dispensed with if it became "flawed". Reducing effective funding over a period of years appears to have "done the trick", as many Canadians now think it doesn't work well and should at least have a "competing" private system.
The problem with us, as Canadians, is that our memories are too short and our perceptions too narrow. We "kicked out" the private system because it was unfair, and could even cost lives. (Remember how that little kid in saskatchewan died on the way to a place where his parents could afford to have him treated?) Universal healthcare was an excellent and socially just program that made me proud of our country's government and its compassion for its citizens.
Since our government started pandering to the corporate interests south of the border, it has lost any compassion for its citizens. It uses us now only to further its agenda for privatization.
The simple truth of the matter is that I, like most Canadians don't mind spending my tax money on such a good program, but that means diddlysquat to the fascists in Ottawa. We have to fight this stupid move to privatization of healthcare. To do so, we'll have to get rid of the Parties that have been bought off by the major corporate forces; which by now includes the Consevatives, Liberals and quite possibly the NDP. Vote for a commie, or a construction worker, or anyone who isn't one of these and I guarantee we'll get better, more honest government. As far as competence goes, even a village idiot could make more intelligent decisions than the crew we have now.
I think his highest level of education was a correspondence course to become a receptionist.
Here's a radical idea: private or public, fix health care by focusing on taking it away from the supply-siders and politicians. This means government is responsible for:
- price controls, to insure against supply choking and price gouging
- public investment in underserviced areas to meet national standards
- financing medical costs for all Canadians, guaranteed full reimbursement at tax time. Since medical expenses are filed at tax time, they are demand-driven. Fraud is covered by existing tax law. Financing health care becomes a task of debt service, not supply-side planning.
Maybe this sounds silly. But my point is to separate the decision of how many beds to close, how many MRIs to operate, which regions get better service, etc., from the decisions regarding how to raise and allocate the public revenue to cover it. The former proceeds according to "market" demand (i.e. need), the latter in response to that demand, as an unalterable obligation of government, and by extension, we as taxpayers, to cover our own costs. Would taxes go up? Maybe. Maybe not. If licensed private providers can deliver the same service cheaper, they'd go down. Same if Canadians became on aggregate healthier or younger. The point is the politicians and bean counters wouldn't get as easy a chance to create supply-side tyrannies up-front, nor would their counterparts in the private sphere.
"Or is it just opening the door to a market based system, supply on demand, price goes up according to demand, so if everybody needs a certain surgery whoops, price goes up, is that what we can expect?"
Only if supply is deliberately constrained.
Another point that needs to be brought out is doctors' support through their professional body (union) for a parallel private system. They claim to support such because of concern for patient care but when these hospitals were being lost neither the CMA nor the AMA had anything substantial to say (actually, I can't think of one single protest from either body) on the matter. There was only one family doctor in Calgary who really protested these actions. On the other hand, now these doctors seem to have all the solutions; the only problem is they all involve methods that result in them making a million dollars per year plus. These people now have no credibility in this debate since it is obvious their primary concern is financial gain for themselves.
Healthcare funding has been constantly increasing in the past few years. Everybody agrees, that did help swing the quality of healhcare in a positive way. On the opposite, while more and more money was thrown at the system, the quality has been going down the drain. Practically no money was spent on long term projects such as hospital facilities, diagnostic machines such as MRI, etc.
Some X-Ray machines are so outdated (think 60s), doctor are not always able to tell whether a bone is broken or not due to poor resolution.
The money is mostly going to waste via inefficiencies, lack of proper processes. Then there were staff shortages, being filled by new hires, wage increases. That is where the money is going. Staff shortages are for a reason - because of lack of proper procedures, staff are mostly inefficient in their work and consequently tasks required demand more people to perform them.
All of these issues are issues of extremely poor management. Hospital management is the root of the problem.
Until this problem is resolved, no matter how much money we throw at the system, it will not be fixed. The funds WILL be swallowed just the same.
There was a huge backlash from hospitals when gov-t wanted to make hospitals accountable and provide detailed reports of daily activities and costs. It is quite obvious why that never fully realized.
The system does not work and will not be fixed by further funding until these issues are resolved. If they cannot be resolved, then competition needs to allowed from private sector. Let the rich pay for their healthcare twice, once through taxes, and second time through insurance. There will be more money left for the public sector since some percentage of people will abandon the public system. Once management issue will be resolved, quality of public care will be improved through this additional money remaining unclaimed by users of private system.
You make some strong accusations e.g :
"Staff shortages are for a reason - because of lack of proper procedures, staff are mostly inefficient in their work and consequently tasks required demand more people to perform them."
and
"Hospital management is the root of the problem".
I'd like to know from what experiences you draw these conclusions.
Frank