N.B. Report Calls For Public Insurance System

Posted on Friday, April 02 at 13:59 by N Say
here's the report put out by the committee:
consultation

here's a story from the CBC:
N.B. report calls for public insurance system

Here's a Chomsky quote about what happened in Ontario ~10yrs ago:
"In the Province of Ontario, you know there is a so-called free-trade agreement between Canada & the United States, in the Province of Ontario, legislation was proposed to institute a no-fault, publicly-funded insurance plan for auto insurance. That would be much cheaper & much more efficient than the current privately-supported plan. The situation is analogous to the health system - it would be a system like the health system - you cut back a ton of bureaucracy & administrative costs, it becomes more efficient, it's also tax-based rather than individually-funded so it's not so regressive & so on. Well that didn't get very far. It was challenged by US insurance companies who claimed that it was in illegal interference with free trade because it interfered with their abilities to operate profitably in Canada. The Province of Ontario could have proceeded with litigation on this matter but they dropped it; it would have been much too expensive and the insurance companies have all the money & all the time & the fancy lawyers & so on, the public doesn't. So Ontario dropped it. If it had gone through the procedures specified by the free-trade agreement, it would have worked its way up to an adjudication panel, which operates in secret & is made up of corporate lawyers and trade representatives & you can guess what the outcome of that will be, and that's typical."

Note: consultation N.B. report calls for ...

Contributed By



Article Rating

 (0 votes) 

Options




Comments

  1. Sat Apr 03, 2004 2:42 am
    I wish we had a publicly funded auto-insurance program. I know that won't happen without a NDP government.

    Kevin

  2. Sat Apr 03, 2004 3:52 am
    Interesting report about public insurance in NB N Say. Thanks for
    the Chomsky quote too!

    We have a riled-up populace here in the city of stately apathy...
    Fredericton, and throughout the province for that matter. There's
    tremendous pressure on Bernard Lord's conservative government
    to adopt those recommendations. Doesn't one of the prairie
    provinces have public auto insurance? As for the American
    insurance companies filing suit, as George Bush would say... Bring
    'em on!!!

    In a totally unrelated story, they've just announced cuts to NB civil
    service to the tune of approximately 750 full-time positions, <insert
    sarcastic tone> but have managed to retain a 2.5% increase for
    members of the legislature. The arrogance, ingnorance, and
    cynicism of most of our elected representatives is truly staggering.

  3. by N Say
    Sat Apr 03, 2004 4:19 am
    BC, Saskatchewan, Manitoba & Quebec all have what NB is considering. It was the NDP that made them all I think, including the attempt in Ontario.

    ---
    "So many right-wing Christians, so few lions." - t-shirt I saw @ school

  4. Sat Apr 03, 2004 2:41 pm
    Elizabeth Wier, leader of the provincial NDP here, spear-heads that and many other efforts to address social issues such as gambling addiction, environment, etc. that the Liberals or Conservatives would otherwise prefer to ignore. If it weren't for her activism, we wouldn't be discussing auto- insurance at all.

  5. Sat Apr 03, 2004 3:49 pm
    Anger about auto insurance is probably the biggest cause for concern among 'ordinary Canadians' who don't have the time to learn and worry over other big picture items. In Ontario private auto insurance companies recorded a 637% (six hundred and thirty seven percent!) increase in profits over last year (over 1 billion dollars!) meanwhile many former drivers (including me!) can no longer afford auto insurance due to increasing rates.

    In four years of driving with a clean record my auto insurance increased (as a secondary driver mind you) from $800 a year to $1200 a year on a car that decreased in value over the same time. A fifty percent increase!

    Many stories a the same kind are abundant in Ontario (and I guess other prov's with private systems) and I think is one of the best ways of showing citizens that corporate interests are in control and not to be trusted.

    Case: during the last Ontario provincial election (where the NDP made a committment to public auto insurance) I was eating at pizza pizza. The young italian guy manning the stove told me he always sees me reading the paper, and wanted to ask me a couple questions about Canadian politics. 'Sure!' says I and here's the first questions he asked.

    1) How does Canadian government work? Is it corrupt?
    2) Who is going to fix auto insurance?

    Canadians know that there is something wrong with the way government works. They just don't know what they can do about it with so much misinformation and confusion surrounding politics. The quickest way to help citizens understand politics is not to wade into NAFTA and Chapter 11 (unless they ask for it :) but to connect problems they have with government and business and inform them of what can be done about it.

    ---
    If we are standing still we are moving backwards.

  6. Sat Apr 03, 2004 7:23 pm
    Yeah with that NAFTA nonsense in place, I wish NBer's the best of luck because their little idea will have been dead before it even gets off the ground. This is totally insane. We've become corporate slaves.

  7. Sat Apr 03, 2004 8:56 pm
    On essential services, the private sector fails again!!! I know we have this anvil called NAFTA hanging over our heads, but the government has got to scrap it! This will kill our public healthcare system too.

    ---
    Dave Ruston



view comments in forum


You need to be a member and be logged into the site, to comment on stories.




Your Voice

To post to the site, just sign up for a free membership/user account and then hit submit. Posts in English or French are welcome. You can email any other suggestions or comments on site content to the site editor. (Please note that Vive le Canada does not necessarily endorse the opinions or comments posted on the site.)

canadian bloggers | canadian news