It is the vestigial remains of the old British Aristocracy, the House of Lords. In much the same way we have the vestigial remains of our reptilian past in our brains. It comes from the power of the rentier class over the rising bourgeois in England. To be a Senator you must be over 30, own $4,000 dollars in property, and be a Canadian citizen. Reformed it becomes a bourgeois institution delayed.
"Saskatchewan Premier Lorne Calvert said on Wednesday that it's irrelevant whether senators are elected or appointed because the chamber is ineffectual as it stands."
We need real political reform in Canada, including proportional representation, the right of recall (as the David Emerson affair has proven), and the right to referendum. All demands made by the labour left at the turn of last century. Which were then ripped off by the right wing populists of Preston Manning's Reform Party. Now joyfully abandoned by the Harpocrites in Ottawa.
We must create sovereign/popular constituent assemblies, not controlled by the State or political parties, to reform this "Con" federation to take into consideration of workers and citizens rights, municipality rights, aboriginal nations and the Quebec nation, and to reform provincial powers so that they match national reforms.
Read the rest of the article here;
http://plawiuk.blogspot.com/2006/03/abolish-senate.html
[Proofreader's note: this article was edited for spelling and typos on March 8, 2006]
Note: http://plawiuk.blogspot...

An elected senate in my opinion is the way to go. You want to have a second house to review bills since the commons is much more politicized and susceptible to the winds of change. A decent elected senate would be that "sober second thought" if it was set up right. Elected for terms of say 10 or more years but never in a Commons election year, with equal provincial (and territorial) representation provided. I'd almost prefer the senators to be elected until they reach a certain age (say 70) so that you wouldn't get vast swings in the politics of the upper house - and to moderate the viewpoints in the senate.
An elected and equal Senate with clear oversight powers would be a good counter balance to the House of Commons. The Senate could be a test bed for mixed member voting or some other form of pro-rep-gov before introducing it for general elections for the House.
---
If there was ever a time for Canadians to become pushy - now is the time - for time is running out on this nation called Canada.
---
Dave Ruston
---
"All great truths begin as blasphemies" - George Bernard Shaw
Go look it up. Again, in order just to INCREASE the number of senators Mulroney had to go to Britain. Go read up on the powers of lieutenant governors and governor generals, they represent the QUEEN.
---
Dave Ruston
<br />
— The Divine Symphony, by Inayat Khan<br />
---
"A Liberal is someone who refuses to take his own side in a fight".
-Robert Frost
The Japanese were potential enemy spies and combatants and a very small group. Interning them was no big deal, and they were treated much better as I mentioned above than Canadian POWs in Japan.
Apologizing for actions that took place in a different historical context is revisionism. The Japanese would have had no qualsm about vapourizing everyone else on the planet had they had the ability to--that's just how they think.
---
"A Liberal is someone who refuses to take his own side in a fight".
-Robert Frost
Absolutely! No tinkering with the system but change it to direct democracy so the people - for once in history - can actually have a say in what goes on, rather than being bullied by a collection of politicoes, corporation bosses and bureaucrats. All power to the people!