The majority of Canadians receive their TV signals through cable or satellite; therefore, it would be easy to regulate access to US programming. Let's not forget that many US services are still banned from Canada, and several other US stations are available through premium packages only. It would be easy enough to implement the same measure for all US networks.
With US networks effectively turned into pay-TV in Canada, a lot of Canadians would have to rely on Canadian broadcasters to watch their favourite shows. I don't have any stats at this point, but from anecdotal evidence I know that a lot of Canadians, perhaps even most Canadians, subscribe to basic cable only (even in today's digital age - the US package could be sold as a digital bundle and thus also serve as an incentive for Canadians to get digital cable, which would benefit all the Canadian diginets).
Without any direct competition from US networks, Canadian broadcasters would be free to pick and choose the "real winners" of any given TV season. In fact, CTV, for example, would not have to jump right in and risk buying a show that gets cancelled within the first few weeks of the season. They could wait it out and then snatch up any shows that have proved to be ratings winners south of the border.
As a matter of act, we could avoid a lot of the rubbish altogether. So many US shows are simulcast by Canadian broadcasters simply because they are widely available on basic US networks.
Case in point: Kelsey Grammer's sketch show. Global only picked it up, because they felt that Canadians would watch it on FOX. Well, it was axed within a few weeks, but Global had spent good money on a show that was never meant to be.
If our broadcasters were no longer "forced" to simulcast every single show from the US (good or bad), they'd have more room in their schedules for - hey, here's an idea - Canadian shows. At this point, we would also know whether they really meant it when they said, "We'd love to do Canadian shows, but we have to keep up with the Jonses in the States, and that doesn't leave us any room for Canadian shows."
As I said, I can appreciate a good US show as much as the next Canadian, but I find it shameful and embarrassing that the second largest country in the world does not have an independent TV industry (on paper we may have it, but the reality is completely different).
The next step would involve ensuring that all Canadians have access to all Canadian broadcasters (CH, for example, is still missing from Alberta). In other words, CBC, CTV, Global, CH, A-Channel and CityTV would have to be at the very front-end of every cable dial on every cable system across Canada.
Of course, there are Canadians who live close enough to the border to pick up US signals off-air. But the quality of these signals is usually less than mediocre, and not all US networks can be received in this way.
I believe this is the only (logical) solution for protecting the sovereignty of our TV industry. And, finally, let's not forget that American cable operators do not carry Canadian stations. So, why should we make theirs freely available?
[Proofreader's note: this article was edited for spelling and typos on June 7, 2005]
Comments
view comments in forum
You need to be a member and be logged into the site, to comment on stories.
As the FCC further restricts artistic expression in the U.S. I wouldn't be surprised if HBO moves to Canada completely. Especially if the American Taliban get their way and extend current obsenity laws to US cable programming which is currently exempt.
Moving US signals to premium would mean that the US networks would have to get the money wouldn't it? Further, it would take basic programming and make it available only to 'elites'.
And if we had decent Canadian networks with a reasonable amount of Canadian content and good programming, there would be no need for an "elite", as you put it, to hang on to US channels.
That's in essence what they have done in the UK. The five basic off-air broadcasters (BBC1, BBC2, ITV, Channel 4, Channel 5) show only a limited number of US series, while the bulk of US programming is relegated to premium cable and satellite services. In other words, if you live in the UK and want to get your fix on US shows, you'll have to pay extra (and substantially so). It would only be fair for Canada to do the same.
I do notice that anywhere in BC that I go, I can watch all the Seattle stations and FOX! Maybe you should let the viewers decide what they want to watch, rather than be concerned about limiting or regulating what they choose?
Canadian TV channels might have limited commercial appeal in the US, as they are principally showing the same crap as the the US channels, and the domestic Canadian news has very limited interest/impact to anyone other than us border dwellers.
You've just described 90% of Canadians (living within 100 miles of the US border)!
Season 1 of Atlantis won't be shown here, and Season 8 of SG1 is just being shown here starting this Thursday - but I've already purchased them on DVD! I'd pay for them on PPV cable, if they were available.
All 3 shows are shot, and effects done in Vancouver.
---
"If you must kill a man, it costs you nothing to be polite about it." Winston Churchill
All these shows are available to Canadian cable viewers.
SG-1 is available on SPACE and other CHUM stations. Stargate Atlantis has aired on Movie Central/The Movie Network and will move to CHUM this fall. Battlestar Galactica has been broadcast on SPACE.
Everything has been fully available - at the same they were available to US viewers (Stargate Atlantis, for example, premiered on Movie Central/TMN at the same time it premiered in the US, and the same is true for Battlestar).
It would appear that you consult all the wrong resources and are therefore left in the dark all the time.
Movie Central is also a pay channel, so not all viewers can get it
I consult the Space and SciFi channel's program listing on their websites. Sometimes they do not include all options.
---
"If you must kill a man, it costs you nothing to be polite about it." Winston Churchill
---
Every time you complain about the moderators, god kills a kitten.
The second seasons of Battlestar and SG Atlantis will be launched simultaneously in the US and Canada (i.e., SPACE and Movie Central, respectively).
FYI: the first season of SG Atlantis will air on CHUM, as I said, and it will be available all over Canada (former A-Channels in the West will become CityTV), and it will also air on SPACE nationwide.
Incidentally, I also worked on Battlestar Galactica: my wife and I produced various foreign-language subtitles for the mini-series.
So, my taxes were used to produce the shows, and I subscribe to cable, but they still haven't become available for me to watch on my TV. Of course, through the miracle of bittorrent, I've already seen them. It just irks me that Canadians paid to produce them, but the rest of the world has seen them, and we haven't had that opportunity.
---
"If you must kill a man, it costs you nothing to be polite about it." Winston Churchill
---
"If you must kill a man, it costs you nothing to be polite about it." Winston Churchill