The Wisdom of Protectionism. The Madness of Free Trade.
Part One
The over-populous of the globe, like herds of driven lemmings, hurtle towards the edge.
Uncontrolled greed exhausts the world’s foodstuffs. Uncontrolled greed exhausts the world’s raw materials and wastes them in destruction of the environment. Uncontrolled greed pollutes the financial system, the economies of the world and legal structures everywhere. And all over the world starvation, deprivation, and war are the only constant facts. The most greedy people form ‘reconstruction’ committees - to invent new disguises for their acts of looting.
Penitent bankers, investment moguls – what have been called “the American Oligarchs”, a small group with too much power and too much money and tireless greed, gather with co-operating politicians around tables to apologize and to make sure no serious change takes place in the way the human community lives and uses and destroys the globe.
In all the places where the world most needs law the greedy make sure no law exists. For fifty years, and more, the greedy of the world have been destroying law. In those years – with a huge campaign of lies and seductive propaganda – the greedy have been unpicking any restraint upon the criminal pursuit of personal wealth. In a hundred ways they have been telling populations they are better off to lose control of the production of food, of sustained manufacturing, and of sound and whole local economies – AND of the financial and credit machinery the country uses.
They have been preaching those things – from the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund, corporate headquarters, from economic think-tanks, from universities, and from the political parties the greedy have created and financed.
Deep, now, is the sickness. And greed so solidly holds positions of power that the U.S. is locked into suicidal “recovery” programs. Looted populations (outside the USA) are making their first open rebellions in an attempt to begin a genuine New Way – so far without significant success.
If it didn’t begin in Venezuela in the 1990s with the coming to power of Hugo Chavez, maybe the Argentinians began it in 2002, marching in the streets, chanting “they all have to go”, forcing out four presidents in three weeks. More recently, Icelanders have driven out their government (literally), rejecting it, their own banks privatized and turned ‘pirate’, the International Monetary Fund, and the political parties in existence. The beginning of real change is uncoordinated, without unifying political philosophy, so far. But it is beginning.
The task can’t be underestimated. Not only do governments in power have to be replaced and many, many of the top bankers and financiers. The International Monetary Fund and the World Bank have to be destroyed. They provide, presently, the only recourse some bankrupt countries have – and the two organizations guarantee further impoverishment of the populations they pretend to “serve” (on behalf of the present criminals of the banking and financial systems). That the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund are, presently, “advising” reformers in the U.S. and elsewhere is proof positive that nothing will change, unless forced.
Repeated in Latvia, riots have not gained significant change, yet. Nor have they in Greece where the foolish police killing of a fifteen year old was followed by days of rioting – excuse to rail against the rape of the country by the wealthy looters.
Nor has the inaudible revolution in Canada, yet, achieved any visible change. In early December 2008, the ugly Harper sleaze briefly awakened the other parties. The Harperites pretended no economic problems existed – all was as it should be as greed raped the ordinary population. For the first time in Canadian history real movement towards a left-centrist coalition was formed, forcing the Harperites to a pretense of change, a pretense at a shift of loyalties.
Betrayed by the wealthy looters who support the Liberal Party, the coalition fell apart, its next emergence guaranteed to happen under conditions (certain to come) made tellingly more dire because failure happened in the first attempt.
The “people”, so far, don’t see the picture clearly. And they can’t, yet, because the lie machine is so successful. The rebuilding that has to come about requires central banks to become the sole creators of money, assisted by secure, stable, and carefully regulated private banks. The rebuilding requires that the corrupt banks and other financial institutions be permitted to go bankrupt (with protection for the innocent). It requires a whole operation to employ local populations – and, where necessary – to restrain the flood of imports (called Protectionism by opponents of the idea).
What is required is a return to the full utilization of natural resources at home and the development of food resources that have been abandoned over decades. Canada’s present “Free Trade” (?) agreements must be erased. I watched, over decades – for instance - canneries in British Columbia taken over, their feeder orchards and farms destroyed, the canneries closed – and the local food operations replaced by imports from large foreign corporations.
Before the collapse of economies, people were becoming aware of the waste and stupidity in such so-called ‘globalization’. People began pushing, especially, for the consumption of food stuffs grown and prepared locally – to end huge transportation costs, waste of energy, slave economy production, corporate irresponsibility, and contamination from abroad. Before the crash, people were becoming aware. The crash has simply increased the number of people informed.
It seems strange, perhaps, that the little, local, “grow our own food” movements should be directly connected to the huge financial and economic crash we are experiencing. But it isn’t strange at all – everything links in the new, corrupted social system.
Everything links, because the fifty years of destroying laws that protect civil society, and the movement into place (globally) of organizations that serve “crimes without laws”, and the internationally linked political structures erected to de-rail democratic responsibility have been – and are still at the present – powerfully effective.
The “people”, so far, don’t see what’s been going on, because the slow ascendancy to power of unrestrained, private, corporate greed has been so smooth and so favourably propagandized that it has seemed almost invisible. Besides, people cannot believe greed can be so intense - that the greedy don’t care if the very planet is destroyed in their lunge for personal wealth. Even the terms people have been given to use have fake meanings – protectionism, free trade, free markets, free enterprise, nationalism – and many more.
The over-populous of the globe, like herds of driven lemmings, hurtle towards the edge. But they aren’t lemmings. They are human beings. And as they realize what is driving them towards destruction they will demand change. They have already begun demanding. That’s why this is called “Part One”, because unpicking the lies and showing what has really been going on will take a column or two more after this one.

Excellent stuff, Robin.
Which is okay, brother. Reality is about to settle in on all those with their heads in the sand, and bite them on their asses. Is already doing so.
And that is the point, which the wingnut presumptions about people misses, and is destined to turn around and bite THEM on the ass in turn. They are peaceful people, just wanting to make their livings, have babies and raise their children, and retire in old age to modestly comfortable lives. They are NOT greedy, as are the ruling classes that take advantage of them and their relative simplicity, and they are content with their relatively simple lives if they would be left reasonably to be so.
They are, however, certainly not lemmings. Indeed, driven to distraction and no fucking choice, they can find the ways and means to resist unbelievably, dragging their guillotines through the streets, lopping off the heads of the greedy "individualists" who rationalize their exploitation and really drive the class war.
A new wind is blowing, and you really do not need to be a weatherman to know which way the wind blows. A new reality is already taking shape, and with it will come the forces needed for the next round in the class war. And they, the self-serving "individualists" of the world, have to win every round. We only have to win once.
We couldn't do it without the fuckups of you wingnuts. Thanks for this.
Coyote
If you want to coast through life doing little more than taking up space and procreating, you have every right to do so. But if your neighbour is willing to work harder, think harder, contribute more and take more risks than you, he deserves to live better than you (at least in material terms). And there is nothing wrong or immoral about him wanting to do so. The desire for a better life is a powerful and positive motivator - far more effective than altruistic platitudes about helping your fellow man and serving the "common good". The keepers of the so-called "common good" are politicians and bureaucratic and academic elites who want to control us and mould us in the shape of their "visions".
If I work harder and contribute more than you do, but I'm not allowed to have a higher standard of living that you, then I'm going to stop working so hard and put my passion and energy into personal pursuits (such as hobbies) which don't benefit you one bit. I refuse to be a host for parasites. The irony is that without the ambitious and driven, the clock-watchers and slackers of the world would have a far poorer standard of living. It's not a zero-sum game. My having a bigger house doesn't necessitate your having a smaller one.
It only becomes "greed" when it's excessive. In appropriate magnitudes, it is the fuel of our prosperity. And as I've said in other posts, give me greed over envy any day.
Our whole system depends on many people being less smart than others. Thus, the proverbial "hockey player" can make a killing by having suckers pay outrageoous amounts for what has become a mediocre "sport".
Just as hundreds of thousands of people signed up for houses they couldn't afford, so that a few could make hundreds of millions.
The "right" insists on spreading such simplistic fictions, as in the following:
http://netrightnation.com/index.php?opt ... g&Itemid=7
but can never present examples of successful, ongoing application, nor can they formulate all the nuances and complexities of the real world within their ideology.
And no matter how much individual members of the ruling class think they did it all themselves and THEIR WAY, we all know that's bullshit. Lots of "little" folks made it for them, is the fact of the matter. The ruling class just got control of the distribution system, and who gets what share, allowing for the Property Laws of Capitalism that favour them, and keep stealing share from those who do the grunt work for them, until working class folks are impoverished into the dirt. And can't buy their shit anymore, and the whole system goes into collapse mode. (Unless the workers are well organized and ready to fight in the mud, the blood and the beer for share),
Do your chest thumping somewhere else. All of us, or most of us here anyway, are onto you and the entire ruling class system. What goes around, comes around, and we're getting ready to tee off on the ruling class hosers, and their wanker "wannabe" supporters again.
Worked hard all my goddamn life, and so does every other living soul I know. (The only thing that's surprising in capitalism is, that everybody isn't a card carrying "shirker".
Coyote
My my, I guess nobody told the boy that the government and the bureaucratic and academic elites are owned lock, stock and barrel by the ruling class, they refer to them as useful idiots. These useful idiots are controlling and moulding us into the forms dictated to them by their ruling class masters. And let us not forget that it was your entrepreneurial psychotic class that brought us all the problems seeking to engulf the world today. The ruling class motto is "We are not happy until you are not happy."
Here's how it works. The "billionaries" wouldn't pay hockey players high salaries if there wasn't a return on investment. That return comes from ordinary people who will pay the price of a ticket if their team displays top-flight talent and has a chance of winning the game. If people were just has happy to pay to watch a losing team, that ROI would disappear and you'd have low salary caps as quickly as you could say...well, ROI.
So ordinary people, exercizing their market power, create the environment in which rich guys bid against each other for star hockey players. As with anything else, the only effective way to assign a value to something is how much of something else one is willing to part with for it.
It's not a zero sum game.
"Everybody works hard, and everybody is needed and important in the larger scheme of things"
No, not everybody works hard. No, not everybody is important. And no, not everyone can be a winner. It's that kind of kindergarten morality (giving ribbons to everyone, everyone has to share their toys) that so many Canadians seem to be stuck in. Time to move up to Grade 1 at least.
"The ruling class just got control of the distribution system, and who gets what share, allowing for the Property Laws of Capitalism that favour them, and keep stealing share from those who do the grunt work for them, until working class folks are impoverished into the dirt."
You speak as if the "distribution system" were something that existed separately from the private economy. If there were no investors or entrepreneurs, would the factories simply have spouted up magically from nowhere? That's a convenient myth to hold for someone who argues that the "workers" create all value. The truth is a little more complicated than that.
"What goes around, comes around, and we're getting ready to tee off on the ruling class hosers, and their wanker 'wannabe' supporters again."
Such hostility. Before you were waxing eloquent about how the "ruling class" would be peaceful "grandfathered" into the new order. Now it's all guillotines and teeing off. You're the one thumping your chest, not me.
Hell, you ain't seen real hostility yet either. Though it's coming, and you will.
And I still advocate... that element of the old order ruling class that co-operates with ordinary folks "on the day", and in the events leading up to and thereafter, be "grandfathered" out of their privileged class position. (We've learned a thing or two about divide and rule too, our wingnut pet monkey.
It never is, without a history of impoverishment, brutality, exploitation and violence toward them, the working class that first picks up and uses the weapons of violence. It is something, the "defencive" actions of "the people", that the most brutal elements of the ruling class brings down upon themselves with their own violent ways. Be they otherwise, and they co-operate "on the days", I would be the first to order steins of beer all around.
Outside of that, you and I don't really have anything we agree on or can talk about. You see the working class as lazy and greedy shits, and I see you as grasping, greedy shits. It is unlikely our twain shall ever meet. It is the unbridgeable divide.
And as for "entrepreneurship", it is not a knowledge or a gift exclusive only to the "acquisitive" amongst us, that drops down from the heavens onto the gifted few with halos. It is a learnable skill not totally unlike say, plumbing or carpentry. (And even the ruling class, especially the old money ruling class, they surround themselves with schooled advisers and expertise, 'cause they themselves don't really know jackshit. I, for example, used to know Chunky Woodwards, hardly intimately, but enough...And he always used to love to have his sycophantic flunkies, like yourself, talking about what a "self made man" he was. He'd puff up like an arrogant peacock. Hell, the real Chunky didn't really know jack. He just fell into it, like a chamber pot full of shit, by right of a privileged birth he'd inherited.)
So, like I say, go flog yourself. There ain't nobody here that weeps for the poor, hard done by and misunderstood ruling class. Your wannabe buddies don't even know what REAL work is. They just like to think they do.
Coyote
Hell Milt, I may steall that line and declare it my own. Good one.
And it really is that way because, given the twisted logic of the so-called "entrepreneurial" ruling class, the only way they know when they've squeezed the pig to its maximum "profit" potential is... when the pig squeals. They can then go to bed happy knowing, that they have squeezed the working class pig until it hurts.
The price of a thing is not really determined so much by the actual costs of production; the labour, material and other inputs, as it is by "What the market will bear."
Again, squeeze the consumer (run up the price), like you did the worker, both of whom are essentially the exact same folks getting hosed twice, at work and in the "free" marketplace, until the pig squeals. And she/he squeals when she/he can't afford the "price" on the "wages" they make anymore... working for "the man".
It's called "capitalism". Ain't it grand?
It's beautiful in its simplicity really. Once you understand the nature of the con, and are no longer a "mark" per se.
Coyote
Economics is not religion... though it is very often treated as so by these "in awe" wingers. By and large, economics is common sense, the essentials of which is within the understanding capacity of certainly most of ordinary humanity. It is, afterall, only making a living raised to a slightly higher level.
Outside of "old wealth" that has typically inherited its wealth generations ago, not infrequently as a consequence of old chicanery and fraud, and command the heights of capitalism, even allowing for the very small number of nouveau riche "entrepreneurs", not infrequently after a history of from a few to many failures and chicanery of their own, whom like the working class in their situation, ever manage to break out of the "small business" strata to become major "corporate capitalists", what in fact typically occurs is, as the business begins to grow and even approach "major" status, often thanks to the cheap labour subsidy of their workforce, the original entrepreneur discovers he is in over his "knowledge and physical capacity head". This "entrepreneur" then seeks, as he/she can afford it, to bring in "schooled professional" managerial and finance specialist help to run it more and more for him. (It is one of the early goals of many an entrepreneur in fact.) The original "entrepreneur" withdraws to the sidelines overseeing from a distance, if at all, and getting reports and analyses from that "professional help" whom, over time, come to actually be the brains and expertise behind the operation, even taking it to the stock market. Which is not to put down the guy with the original "lucky" idea at all, but to recognize that in the world of the future, are we so fortunate to grow a truly "democratic co-operative" as opposed to continuing the predatory "heirarchical competitive" economic system arrangement, there is no reason at all why "co-ops" of workers, communities, and interest groups cannot themselves hire and fire managerial/entrepreneurial skills themselves... as I say, not unlike we currently hire plumbing and carpentry "contractors", or even chartered accountants .
This "entrepreneurial mystique" with which the ruling class and their apologists seek to surround themselves, while "entrepreneurial skills" ARE important, is not voodoo, magic or something beyond the reck and ken of the working class to understand, hire and control through ordinary day to day "democratic" and oversight means.
Economic science, once we stop hiding its essentials behind (esoteric) gobbly gook words designed only for the select inner circle of initiates, to hide understanding from ordinary people in fact, and make it actually intelligible to the busy lives of ordinary people instead, is entirely capable of being understood and utilized by them, especially across one or two generations, if a serious effort is made and folks come to understand its importance.
Entrepreneurs per se, are not Gods possessing mysterious "other worldly" powers bestowed from Mt. Olympus. They are mere mortals whose shit stinks the same as the rest of us.
Coyote
You're the one who keeps bringing class into it, not me. All classes have people who are lazy and greedy and who crave the unearned.
What you call "grasping", I call the desire for a better life. All you should be entitled to in this society is basic survival and a minimum standard of health. Anything above that should be earned.
If someone creates a product that nobody wants, it is worth nothing. Zero. Zilch. It doesn't matter how much labour went into creating it, how much energy was consumed in its creation or what raw materials went into it. It is worth nothing because nobody wants it. Without that basic market discipline, anyone can make anything and claim to have done useful work, when they may well have simply wasted energy, resources and time that could have been applied to something people actually wanted.
The ability to organize large numbers of people, pull together resources and bring a vision to life is something only a small number of us can do. Not all of these people are in the private sector, but the private sector tends to draw the best of them. One reason for this is that the incentives are better, and better tied to results. Any fool can build a large bureaucratic empire. But it takes someone very special to run a lean and efficient enterprise which delivers goods or services that customers want at a price they're willing to pay, especially if there's someone else down the street selling the same thing.
The fact that a strong and vibrant free-market conservative movement sprouted up and eventually took power in a country that had endured decades of left-liberal social engineering and electoral manipulation (funded by the taxpayers of course) is a testimony to the fact that the Canadian right has better organizers, managers and planners. This is no accident. Conservatives have these talents because they have honed them elsewhere. The left in Canada can barely organize a bake sale, and the few good leaders they have get mired in interneccine squabbles, usually over how one's group is more oppressed than another or who's interpretation of Marx is more correct, etc.
Those in the "working class" who have ambition and ability and are willing to work hard (and smart) can live very well. For those people who have ambition but lack ability, well, there's always union leadership.
"Outside of "old wealth" that has typically inherited its wealth generations ago, not infrequently as a consequence of old chicanery and fraud..."
I'm actually a big believe in high estate taxes, for this very reason. Besides, silver-spoon types often become champagne socialists, because they have no idea what it took their parents to make the money in the first place.
And I still advocate... that element of the old order ruling class that co-operates with ordinary folks "on the day", and in the events leading up to and thereafter, be "grandfathered" out of their privileged class position. (We've learned a thing or two about divide and rule too, our wingnut pet monkey. ) As for the rest, they will determine for themselves whether they are part of this group... or not-, determined by the civility of their behaviour toward the working class and their demands for economic AND political democracy.
Well, if that day come, I suppose you'd better have your guillotines and gulags ready. Because I have no intention of staying quiet and playing along while my country is turned into Cuba North.